Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage

Crispy browned Sage Butter Potatoes in a bowl with garlic, sage butter glistening on top.
Jump to Recipe

These crispy Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage are an easy and delicious side dish you can make in 30 minutes for a busy weeknight or elegant weekend dinner.  

Crispy browned Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage in a bowl with garlic, sage butter glistening on top.

Today, I take the humble, understated, perhaps even dull potato and turn it into something glorious that you will be proud to serve at dinner!  This is my salty, crispy, irresistible Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage Recipe!  The potato is truly one of the most iconic comfort foods.  It’s filling, warm, creamy, and always available!  But this potato recipe uses small creamer potatoes, cut in halves, then seared in olive oil in a skillet, then finished in a delectable buttery sauce flavored with just a little salt and ground black pepper, garlic, and sage.  Yup, buttered garlic potatoes are where it’s at on your Fall dinner table.

EASY RECIPE FOR BABY POTATOES WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND SAGE

That’s right, this one is super easy!  Just cut the potatoes in halves, sear in a pan, make the sage butter sauce.  These are even easier to make than mashed potatoes.

Crispy browned Sage Butter Potatoes in a skillet with garlic, sage butter glistening on top.

Quick note!  This post contains affiliate links, which means I earn a commission (at no extra cost to you) if you purchase from them.  This commission is what helps me keep this blog afloat :).  I also share these links because I have used the products, genuinely love them, and want you to know exactly what I used. 

RECIPE EQUIPMENT NEEDED

For this easy recipe, you just need a large skillet/frying pan for making the veggies and curry sauce. I use my absolute favorite 12″ Ceramic Pan, which is great because food really does slide right off with minimal oil and I don’t have to worry about food sticking and burning. 

Mincing garlic is made super easy with a Garlic Press.

Crispy browned Sage Butter Potatoes in a bowl with garlic, sage butter glistening on top.

WHAT ARE BABY OR CREAMER POTATOES?

Creamer potatoes are small waxy potatoes that come in red and yellow varieties.  They taste the same regardless of the skin color.  The skin of creamer potatoes is very thin and doesn’t need to be removed.  While they do not oxidize as fast as a russet potato, you will want to store them in cold water in the fridge if you cut them more than a couple hours prior to cooking.  

RECIPE PREP-AHEAD STEPS FOR BUTTER BABY POTATOES

We are all extremely busy and making dinner during the week can be overwhelming. Here are steps you can prepare ahead to save time on busy nights! (See the full recipe below) 

For this baby potatoes recipe, you will cut the potatoes in half the longest side for more surface area.  

Knife cutting a creamer potato in half for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Halved red and gold creamer potatoes on cutting board for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Thinly slice the sage leaves. Mince the garlic.

Knife slicing fresh sage leaves for Sage Butter Potatoes.

 

COOK YOUR SAGE BUTTER POTATOES

Preheat large pan on high heat, then turn to medium, add olive oil, then potatoes cut side down. Turn heat back to high and cook for 3-5 minutes until browned crust has formed. You may need to do in 2 batches.

Halved red and gold creamer potatoes on cutting board for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Once all potatoes are seared, add them all to the pan (if seared in batches) and then add 1 tablespoon of the butter and stir to melt. Cover the pan and cook for 10 minutes on low heat.

After 10 minutes, remove the cover and test a potato with a fork to see if soft. If not, cover and cook for another 4-5 minutes.

Browned and crispy halved red and gold creamer potatoes in a skillet with a fork in one potato for Sage Butter Potatoes.

If done, add the remaining butter, minced garlic, and sage. Stir to melt the butter and cook over low heat for a final five minutes. 

Hand adding minced garlic to skillet with 2 pats of butter and browned and crispy halved red and gold creamer potatoes for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Browned and crispy halved red and gold creamer potatoes in a skillet with garlic, sage, and melted butter for Sage Butter Potatoes.

RECIPE FAQS

How early can I cut the potatoes before cooking?

You can cut them and let them sit out up to 2 hours prior to cooking.  If more than 1-2 hours, you will want to store them in the fridge in cold water to prevent them from oxidizing.  While creamer potatoes are waxy and do not oxidize as fast as a russet potato, you will want to store them in cold water in the fridge if you cut them more than a couple hours prior to cooking.  

Are there any other fresh herbs I could use besides sage?

You could use a very small amount, about 1 teaspoon, of rosemary, cut fine.  Basil and oregano are also great.  For these you would want about a tablespoon chopped.  Dill is also delicious with potatoes!  You could use a tablespoon of dill as well.  Parsley is always great, but really doesn’t impart much flavor.  

Can I cook this recipe ahead and reheat it?

Yes, although they may lose their crispiness after cooling in the fridge.  To re-crisp them, you can reheat the cooked potatoes in a skillet on medium-high heat with a little olive oil.  Or add them to an oven safe skillet and reheat in the oven at 350 F degrees for 20 minutes.

Are potatoes Gluten Free?

Yes, potatoes are naturally gluten free and this recipe is gluten free.  However, you should always check the labels for products that you purchase to ensure they are gluten free if that is what you require.

What to do with leftovers?

Potato Salad, potato salad, potato salad!!!  That’s right, these are amazing in a Loaded Potato Salad with spinach and bacon or in a healthier Edamame and Harissa Potato Salad.  

ENJOY!  😍 Carrie

Crispy browned Sage Butter Potatoes in a bowl with garlic, sage butter glistening on top.

Have you tried this recipe? If so, please leave a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ star rating in the recipe below! I love to hear your feedback and your rating helps others to find this recipe. Thanks so much!

Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage

These salty, crispy, irresistible Baby Potatoes with Garlic Butter and Sage are a perfect side dish for any easy family weeknight or elegant guest dinner!  This recipe uses small creamer potatoes, cut in halves, then seared in olive oil in a skillet and finished in a delectable buttery sauce flavored with just a little salt and ground black pepper, garlic, and sage. Delicious and so EASY to make!

Course Side Dish
Cuisine American, French
Keyword butter potatoes, potatoes, Sage
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Servings 4 servings
Calories 252 kcal
Author Carrie Tyler

Ingredients

  • 1.5-2 pounds Creamer Potatoes (red, yellow, or mixed)
  • 1 tablespoon Extra-virgin olive oil
  • 2 Tablespoons Fresh sage, sliced
  • 4 Tablespoons Salted Butter
  • 1 clove Garlic, minced
  • 1/2 teaspoon Salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon Ground black pepper

Instructions

Prep-Ahead Steps

  1. Cut the potatoes in half the longest side for more surface area
    Halved red and gold creamer potatoes on cutting board for Sage Butter Potatoes.
  2. Thinly slice the sage leaves. Mince the garlic.

    Knife slicing fresh sage leaves for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Cooking Steps

  1. Preheat large pan on high heat, then turn to medium, add olive oil, then potatoes cut side down. Turn heat back to high and cook for 3-5 minutes until browned crust has formed. You may need to do in 2 batches to fit all of the potatoes face-down.

    Halved red and gold creamer potatoes on cutting board for Sage Butter Potatoes.
  2. Once all potatoes are seared, add them all to the pan (if seared in batches) and then add 1 tablespoon of the butter and stir to melt. Cover the pan and cook for 10 minutes on low heat.

  3. After 10 minutes, remove the cover and test a potato with a fork to see if soft. If not, cover and cook for another 4-5 minutes. If done, add the remaining butter, minced garlic, salt, pepper, and sage. Stir to melt the butter and cook over low heat for a final five minutes. Serve and enjoy!

    Browned and crispy halved red and gold creamer potatoes in a skillet with garlic, sage, and melted butter for Sage Butter Potatoes.

Thanksgiving Meal Planner Printable

Thanksgiving Cooking Guide and Schedule

Let’s turn Thanksgiving stress into a relaxed and enjoyable holiday with this Thanksgiving Meal Planner Printable! It will give you everything you need to plan, prepare, and cook a delicious and stress-free Thanksgiving dinner.

The ultimate FREE Thanksgiving Meal Planner Printable for a No-Stress holiday!   Planning tips, menu, turkey tips, 7-day prep checklist, & more!

Hosting Thanksgiving Dinner can be stressful!

Afraid you may end up throwing your turkey across the room vs. serving it to your guests?  I don’t blame you, hosting Thanksgiving can be overwhelming!  How big of a turkey do you need?  What can be made ahead?  How in the world do you get it all done at the same time??  It’s stressful – but it doesn’t have to be!!

Let’s turn Thanksgiving stress into a relaxed and enjoyable holiday!

Your Ultimate Holiday Meal Planner for a No-Stress Thanksgiving

After years being a caterer, making meals for my family, and developing easy dinner recipes on this blog, I have mastered the art of planning and prepping ahead.  So, now I bring all of these plans, tips, tricks, and checklists to you for Thanksgiving!  CLICK HERE TO GET THE FREE THANKSGIVING MEAL PLANNER PRINTABLE!

Here’s what you will be thankful for with this freebie:
* Your entire Thanksgiving Meal planned ahead
* You will know exactly how to buy, store, prepare, and cook your turkey
* A Day-by-Day Prep-Ahead Checklist will help you prepare a little each day during the 7 days before Thanksgiving
* Most of the food prepared ahead of Thanksgiving Day
* You get to relax and enjoy time with your family on Thanksgiving Day!!

What you will get in this Thanksgiving Meal Planner Printable

  1. PLANNING & PREP TIPS CHECKLIST – When it comes to planning any dinner party, there are a few key things to remember that I learned as a caterer in NYC.  Following these tips will help you no matter how big or small the dinner or event. CLICK HERE TO GET THE FREE THANKSGIVING MEAL PLANNER PRINTABLE
  2. PLAN-YOUR-MENU TEMPLATE – You will get a menu template where you can write down your appetizers ideas, main dishes, and side dishes.  There is space to list the dish and the ingredients, along with any notes.
  3. TURKEY TIPS! – Next you will get the best cheat sheet for buying, prepping, and cooking your turkey!  You get tools and equipment, tips for buying and thawing, including how big the turkey should be, steps for cooking your turkey. 
  4. PREP-AHEAD SCHEDULE – I have put together a detailed checklist for each day to prepare your kitchen, dining room, and food in the 7 days ahead of Thanksgiving.
  5. THANKSGIVING DAY COOKING & SERVING SCHEDULE – That’s right, you will get an hourly schedule and checklist to completely start and finish your Thanksgiving Meal!  You also get a blank template so you can create your own.
Picture of Turkey being carved for Thanksgiving Dinner Meal Planner & Prep Guide

Easy Thanksgiving Side Dishes

Holidays can be stressful when it comes to cooking, but they don’t have to be! Check out these Holiday Side Dishes that you can easily make ahead partly or entirely so that you can relax and enjoy the holiday. 

Don’t Miss this Thanksgiving Meal Planning Printable!!

I hope these tips, tricks, guides, templates, and schedules help to make hosting Thanksgiving as easy as possible. Once again, you can get these as part of the FREE Thanksgiving Meal Planner Printable!

HAPPY THANKSGIVING!  😍 Carrie